Discover Slice of the Hamptons, a pizza restaurant in Southampton serving authentic Italian slices, creative specialties like Peter’s Drunken Grandma, and fresh cannoli. Friendly service and top-rated flavors make it a must-visit spot in the Hamptons.
Service: No-contact delivery / Delivery / Takeaway / Dine-in
Nestled in the heart of Southampton, New York, Slice of the Hamptons offers a genuine taste of Italy with a fresh, modern twist. This cozy pizzeria at 20 County Rd 39 is more than just a stop for a quick slice; it's a destination for those who appreciate quality, creativity, and a warm atmosphere.
The restaurant’s menu boasts a variety of specialty pies that cater to diverse palates—from the classic Margherita and vibrant Supreme Veggie to more inventive options like the Shrimp & Street Corn with Alfredo Sauce and the indulgent Philly Cheese Steak. Their cauliflower and thin crusts provide a thoughtful nod to health-conscious diners without compromising on flavor or texture.
What truly sets Slice of the Hamptons apart is its attention to detail and unique flavors. The standout Peter’s Drunken Grandma pie, enriched with a luscious vodka sauce, reveals the chef’s skill and passion for bold, balanced tastes. Alongside traditional Italian favorites such as the Hampton Italian Chicken and Chicken Parmigiana, the menu delivers a satisfying blend of comfort and sophistication.
Customer experiences highlight the warm hospitality and dedication of the staff. Visitors often praise the owner’s friendliness and the care taken in preparation and service, creating an inviting environment that feels like a neighborhood gem. Even discerning pizza lovers from afar, such as visitors from Chicago, find themselves impressed by the depth and authenticity of each slice.
Beyond pizza, the fresh cannoli with fig jam emerges as a divine finish, offering a delicate sweetness that perfectly complements the savory mains. The unique fusion of traditional Italian desserts with innovative touches reflects the restaurant’s overall approach: familiar yet exciting.
Ideally located near a convenient Dunkin Donuts and gas station, Slice of the Hamptons is easily accessible for locals and travelers alike. Whether you’re craving a casual lunch, a hearty dinner, or a quick bite on the way into town, this pizzeria suits a broad audience—from families to food enthusiasts seeking an authentic Italian experience in the Hamptons.
In essence, Slice of the Hamptons is a culinary haven where classic Italian flavors meet thoughtful innovation. For those who value quality ingredients, inventive recipes, and genuine hospitality, this small yet remarkable spot is a must-visit.
