Menu of Slice of the Hamptons in Southampton, New York, USA

Menu Overview

Slice of the Hamptons is a gem tucked away at 20 County Rd 39, Southampton, NY. This pizza restaurant transcends the typical slice joint experience, offering a true taste of Italy with a local Hamptons flair. Their thin-crust pizzas stand out for their perfect balance—crisp yet tender, topped generously with fresh, thoughtfully sourced ingredients.

The menu is a vibrant showcase of inventive specialty pies. The Supreme Veggie pizza dazzles with a medley of garden-fresh vegetables that burst with flavor in every bite, making it a winner even among meat lovers. Seafood enthusiasts will delight in the Shrimp & Street Corn with Alfredo Sauce, an unexpected yet harmonious blend that combines creamy sauce with sweet charred corn and succulent shrimp. The Peter’s Drunken Grandma with its rich, red sauce and vodka-drizzle leaves a memorable impression, praised widely for its bold and nuanced flavors.

Noteworthy too is the Buffalo Chicken pizza, perfect for those craving a spicy kick, and the BBQ Chicken Ranch, which layers smoky and tangy profiles with finesse. The Street Taco pizza captures vibrant Mexican influences, while traditional favorites like Grandma and Philly Cheese Steak round out the menu with comforting familiarity.

Beyond pizza, Slice of the Hamptons excels with its fresh salads—the crisp Caesar and zesty Greek Salad provide refreshing counterpoints to the richness of the pies. For a true Italian-American experience, the Hampton Italian Chicken Parm Hero is a standout, showcasing expertly breaded chicken layered with savory sauce and melted cheese.

One cannot talk about this spot without mentioning the heavenly Fresh Cannoli that cap off a perfect meal. With a light, crisp shell and luxuriously creamy filling, these cannoli often feature inventive touches like fig jam, adding a sweet complexity that resonates deeply.

Customer testimonials echo my sentiments: the owner’s warm hospitality and the staff’s genuine passion enrich the dining experience. Comments from pizza connoisseurs and casual visitors alike praise the meticulous preparation, creative menu, and unbeatable quality. Whether you’re a native New Yorker or visiting the Hamptons, this place offers pizza that truly competes with the best in the country.

Slice of the Hamptons isn't just another pizzeria—it’s an authentic culinary destination where tradition meets innovation, all wrapped in the charm of the South Fork. For thin-crust pizza lovers and food adventurers alike, it’s a must-visit that consistently delivers remarkable flavor and heartfelt service.